Shingles Vs. Metal Roofing | Which Is Better For Your Home?


Metal and shingle materials are two of the most popular roofing types. But we get asked all the time – which is the better option? The truth is, there’s no “right or wrong” answer to this question. The answer really depends on the application of the roofing, as well as your own personal preferences. But to help you decide, we’re going to take a look at the advantages and disadvantages of each, as well as the differences between the two. So let’s not waste another minute:

What is metal roofing?

Metal roofing is a type of roofing material made from – you guessed it – metal. It can be copper, aluminum, zinc, steel, or tin, each of which has its own advantages and drawbacks. Copper, for example, is extremely long-lasting, while zinc and aluminum are more resistant to corrosion. 

When people think of metal roofing, their first reaction is often to cringe. Most people envision metal roofing as a large chunk of metal on the roof – doesn’t sound very attractive, does it? But in reality, it is designed to be very aesthetically appealing and can resemble a variety of other roofing types. In other words, it doesn’t necessarily look like it’s metal. 

What is shingle roofing?

Roof shingles are the most common type of roofing. They come in a variety of different types and styles and can be used on almost any roofing type. The most common shingle material is asphalt, mainly because it is the most affordable type. 

Shingles are typically designed with overlapping elements and are laid from the bottom of the roof up. In addition to asphalt, shingles can be rubber, wood, slate, and a variety of other materials. For the purpose of this article, however, we are going to refer specifically to asphalt shingles (since they are the most popular). 

What are the advantages of metal roofing?

  • Lightweight. Metal roofing is a very lightweight material. This means that it is easier to handle and install. In addition, it doesn’t add any unnecessary stress to your structure like some other roofing materials can. In return, it helps to preserve the integrity of your structure and building. 
  • Durable. When you install metal roofing, you definitely get your money worth. Metal roofing has a very long lifespan and can last up to 50 years if properly maintained. Depending on the type of material, you may even be able to get more longevity. Copper, for example, has been known to last 100 years or more. 
  • Protects against fire damage. Metal roofing has a Class A fire rating, meaning that it is non-combustible and is resistant to fire. If you live in an area that is prone to wildfires, this factor can be very beneficial. 
  • Stands up well to extreme weather. When compared to some other roofing materials, metal stands up very well to extreme weather conditions like high winds, hurricanes, rain, hail, ice, and snow. 
  • Reduces your carbon footprint. Unlike some other types of roofing materials, metal roofing is an eco-friendly option. Not only is the material itself recyclable, but most metal roofing is actually made up of previously recycled materials. Aluminum roofing, for example, is made up of 95% recycled material. 
  • Can increase your property value. Because metal roofing is so durable and lasts such a long time, it can increase your property value. This is something that you may want to consider if you are looking to sell in the near future. 
  • Low maintenance. When installed properly, metal roofing does not require a lot of maintenance. Like any roofing type, metal roofing requires regular upkeep and inspections, usually twice a year and after any large storms. Aside from that, it is pretty low maintenance compared to other roofing types. 
  • It can lower your insurance premiums. Because metal is more resistant to weather and fire damage, it can lower your home insurance premiums. Speak to your insurance adviser to learn more about this and how metal roofing will affect your policy.
  • You can install it over existing roofing. If you are looking to cut some costs, you can install metal roofing over top of old roofing. This helps to save time, cut down on labor fees, and reduce the amount of waste in the landfill. 

What are the benefits of Shingle Roofing?

  • Shingle Roofing is budget-friendly. When it comes to the upfront fee, shingle roofing is very economical. Shingle roofing is the most affordable form of roofing, which is also why it is the most popular. 
  • Shingle roofing is easy to install. Shingles are pretty basic when it comes to installation and most roofing companies and contractors know how to install it. The installation process is quick and easy, as are replacements. 
  • Repairs are affordable. In the event that something goes wrong with your roofing, repairs are also quite affordable. Most shingle roofs require few materials for repair, so the costs are low.
  • It’s easy to find a qualified contractor. Because shingles are the most basic roofing materials, it’s not difficult to find a qualified contractor. It is still essential to find someone licensed and certified, but they are generally easier to find.
  • It’s easy to find. Some roofing materials can be difficult to find. This isn’t the case with shingles. You can find a variety of different shingle options sold at local retailers and distributors. Shingles come in all different shapes, sizes, and varieties and can match any design. 
  • They have good warranties. Shingle warranties often cover a variety of things including material defects, the growth of algae, wind-resistance, and contractor error. Of course, this will differ based on the manufacturer, so be sure to read over and familiarize yourself with your warranty before purchase. 

Metal Roofing vs. Shingles – Which is the better option for your home?

If you’re looking for durability…. Go with metal roofing. Metal roofing is designed with longevity in mind and can stand up to harsh weather like hurricanes and high winds. Depending on the type of metal you install, your roof system can last from 50-100 years, meaning you won’t have to worry about a new roof again in your lifetime.

If you’re looking to install a roof on a budget…. Go with shingle roofing. Shingle roofing is the most budget-friendly option and there are plenty of different varieties available. Shingle roofing is cheaper to purchase and install.

If you want to go with an eco-friendly option…. Go with metal roofing. Many metal roofing products are made from recycled materials. Plus, when you replace your roof, it’s 100% recyclable. Most types of shingles will end up in the landfill.

If you’re looking for quick and easy installation and repairs…. Go with shingles. Shingle roofing installation doesn’t require any specialized knowledge or skills, so the pros can have it installed quickly and efficiently. When repairs are needed, they usually do not take long to make.

Of course, when selecting materials for your roofing in San Antonio, you also need to consider your roof design. The square footage of your roof, the pitch (slope) of your roof, the complexity of your roof, and the amount of sunlight your roof receives should all be taken into account when deciding which material is the best option for your home. 

Speak to a knowledgeable San Antonio roofing contractor to learn more about your options and what will work best for your needs. 


Schedule a Roof Inspection with the Experts at

McAllen Valley Roofing Co.

Contact Information


5828 Sebastian Pl, Suite 102 San Antonio, TX 78249

Call Now ButtonClick to Call Now